The cold email says "We can get you to #1 on Google in 30 days." The proposal is full of jargon. The salesperson will not tell you who does the work. Sound familiar? Plenty of home-service owners have paid for months and still cannot say what they bought.
The fix is simple: ask the right questions and listen to how the answer sounds. Below are 12 questions to bring to every call, what a solid answer sounds like and what should make you hang up.
Why the questions matter more than the pitch
A good agency welcomes hard questions. A weak one dodges them. You are not trying to catch anyone out. You want to know what you will get, who will do it and how you will know it worked.
12 questions to ask a local SEO company
1. Can you show me results for businesses like mine?
A good answer names the trade, the town and the numbers, and says where the numbers came from: Search Console, Google Business Profile or call tracking. A red flag is a pile of screenshots showing rankings for the agency's own name or keywords nobody searches.
We publish ours on the case studies page. One example is a Paso Robles property management company where we ran three years of local SEO. The page reports 19.8K clicks from Google over 16 months.
2. What results do you expect, and by when?
A good answer gives a range and explains the early signs: first fixes in weeks, steady growth over months. A red flag is a promise. No one can guarantee a #1 ranking.
3. Who actually does the work?
You may sign with a salesperson and be served by someone you never meet. Ask for the name and role of the person who will touch your account, and how to reach them.
4. What do I get each month, in writing?
Ask for deliverables: how many pages, how many posts, how many links, what reporting. "Ongoing optimization" is not a deliverable.
5. How will you track calls and booked jobs?
Rankings do not pay your crew. Calls do. Ask about call tracking numbers, form tracking and how they separate real leads from spam. Our plans include call tracking and a monthly report showing the calls that came from Google.
6. Who owns my accounts?
Your Google Business Profile, Analytics, Search Console and website should be in your name. If the agency owns them, leaving gets painful.
7. How do you get links?
Good answers sound like local sponsorships, supplier pages, chambers of commerce and local news. Be wary of a bulk package of links for a flat fee. Ask to see sample sites first.
8. How do you handle my business name on Google?
Your Google Business Profile name should match your real-world name. A careful agency will not stuff keywords or a city into it. Stuffed names can get a profile suspended.
9. What experience do you have in my trade and my area?
An agency that has worked with plumbers, HVAC crews or roofers understands emergency calls, seasonality and service areas. Ask for one example from your trade. If you work in Texas, ask about your city. We build city pages for Houston and Dallas, for example.
10. How will you tell me about changes to my website?
You should know before pages, titles or redirects change. A good agency sends a short note or monthly summary, not silence.
11. What are the contract terms?
Ask about the minimum term, notice period, setup fees and what happens to your content if you leave. Our plans are month-to-month with 15 days' notice and no setup fee.
12. What do you need from me?
The honest answer is rarely "nothing." Expect to supply photos, account access, a few minutes to approve pages and help collecting reviews. If the agency needs nothing, the work will be generic.
Red flags that end the call
- They email or call you out of the blue promising results.
- They guarantee first place.
- They claim a special relationship with Google.
- They stay vague or secretive about the plan.
- They sell link schemes or mass directory submissions.
- They cannot name one measurable thing they will report each month.
How we answer these questions
We follow five steps: understand the business, audit, build a strategy, do the work, then measure and improve. Plans are on our pricing page. You get a monthly plain-English report. And we start with a free audit so you see how we think before you pay.

